top of page

U.S. Taxation and Reporting of Foreign Trusts: Ten Form 3520-A Traps from the TX Forum on International Tax

Writer: Milan Solarz-Patel
Milan Solarz-Patel
4 days ago
4 min read

On November 12, 2026, I presented "U.S. Taxation and Information Reporting of Foreign Trusts" at the TX Forum on International Tax – Houston Edition, a two-day program of international tax education held in Houston and online on November 12–13, 2026. The forum was organized by Maura Nobile CPA PLLC, and I am grateful to Maura Nobile for the invitation to speak.

The session combined the two subjects on which I am asked to speak most often: how the United States taxes foreign trusts, and where the annual reporting on Form 3520-A and Form 3520 most often goes wrong. A summary follows for those who were unable to attend.

Step One: What Type of Trust Do You Have?

Every foreign trust analysis begins with classification, which proceeds in five steps.

  1. Is the arrangement a trust for U.S. tax purposes? The question is whether a trustee holds title to property for the benefit of beneficiaries. The label under local law does not control: the IRS has ruled that a Mexican fideicomiso is not a trust where the trustee merely holds title, and a Liechtenstein Anstalt, a Stiftung, and a civil law usufruct are each classified on their own terms.

  2. Is the trust domestic or foreign? A trust is domestic only if it satisfies both the court test and the control test. If it fails either test, it is a foreign trust, which is the default rule.

  3. Foreign trust with a U.S. grantor: grantor or non-grantor? If the trust has, or could have, a U.S. beneficiary, grantor trust status is automatic under IRC § 679. If U.S. beneficiaries are explicitly prohibited, the trust is a grantor trust only if the U.S. grantor retains certain powers under IRC §§ 673–677. Otherwise, it is a foreign non-grantor trust.

  4. Foreign trust with a non-U.S. grantor: grantor or non-grantor? The trust is a grantor trust only if the non-U.S. grantor retains the power to revest the trust property, alone or with the consent of a related or subservient party, or if the grantor and the grantor's spouse are the only permitted beneficiaries during the grantor's lifetime. Otherwise, it is a foreign non-grantor trust.

  5. Is the trust simple or complex? A trust that may accumulate income, distribute principal, or make charitable contributions is a complex trust. Most foreign trusts are classified as complex.

How the Trust and Its Beneficiaries Are Taxed

A U.S. owner of a foreign grantor trust reports all of the trust's income, deductions, and credits on a personal U.S. income tax return. A distribution from a foreign grantor trust with a non-U.S. grantor is not taxed to a U.S. beneficiary, although it must still be reported.

The foreign non-grantor trust is where the expense lies. A distribution to a U.S. beneficiary carries out current-year income first, then accumulated income from prior years, and trust principal last. The accumulated income is subject to the throwback tax, which converts favorably taxed income into ordinary income and adds an interest charge that runs from the year in which the income was earned. For income accumulated over many years, the tax and interest can consume most of the distribution. The session also covered the elections, distribution strategies, and restructuring options available to mitigate that result.

Ten Form 3520-A Traps

  1. Who files, and when. The trustee files, but the U.S. owner is responsible. A calendar-year trust files by March 15. Only Form 7004 extends the deadline; the owner's Form 4868 does not. If the trustee fails to file, the U.S. owner must attach a substitute Form 3520-A to Form 3520.

  2. The trust needs its own EIN. A Social Security number or an ITIN is not an acceptable substitute.

  3. The U.S. agent decision. A trust without a U.S. agent must attach its trust documents, including any letter of wishes, to the return.

  4. Income reporting must be consistent. The amounts on the Statement of Foreign Trust Income Attributable to U.S. Owner must agree with the owner's Form 1040.

  5. PFICs. Non-U.S. mutual funds held by the trust generally require a separate Form 8621 for each fund.

  6. The underlying LLC has its own filings. A domestic LLC owned by a foreign trust files Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120. A foreign LLC is a foreign corporation by default and requires Form 5471, unless a timely Form 8832 election is made, in which case Form 8858 is filed.

  7. S corporation stock. A foreign trust cannot be an S corporation shareholder, even where a U.S. person is treated as the owner of the entire trust. The S election terminates on the date of transfer.

  8. Attachments. A Form 3520-A that lacks its required statements is not complete, and a return that is not complete is not treated as timely filed.

  9. Community property. A transfer of community property generally means two U.S. owners, even where the trust deed names one settlor.

  10. Penalties. The penalty for Form 3520-A is generally the greater of $10,000 or 5% of the gross reportable amount; for Form 3520, it can reach 35%. The limitations period does not begin to run until a complete and accurate return is filed.

The Rest of the Program

The forum brought together a strong group of practitioners. The other sessions were:

  • John R. Strohmeyer, Strohmeyer Law PLLC – "No, You Can't Do That With a Trust: Recognizing Scam Trusts Before Clients Get Involved"

  • E. Allan Tiller, E. Allan Tiller, PLLC – "Texas' New Restrictions on Property Ownership by Certain Foreign Nationals"

  • Luis Arturo Morales Páez, Luis M Páez CPA, PLLC – "Dividend or Capital Gain? Selling a CFC with PTEP under §1248, §962, and Installment Reporting"

  • Luke Papaelias and Abbas Somji, Tanager Wealth Management LLP – "Start Strong: Planning Strategies for UK Expats Living in the US"

  • Todd Selby, Melton & Melton, L.L.P. – "AI & Disclosure of Taxpayer Information Concerns"

  • Christine Dahl, Esq., Dahl Tax Law – "Everyday Claude Habits: Create a Skill/Artifact"

  • Anthony (Tony) Malik, EA, Point Square Consulting, Inc. – "Working With Noncompliant International Businesses"

Rory Gleeson was the guest speaker at lunch on Thursday.

How Auric Private Client Advisory LLC Can Help

Auric Private Client Advisory LLC advises on the U.S. tax classification of foreign trusts and their underlying entities, prepares Forms 3520-A and 3520 with the required statements, and coordinates the trust reporting with the preparer of the owner's Form 1040. Where prior-year filings have been missed, the IRS Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures may offer a path back into compliance.

If you are a trustee, an advisor, or a U.S. owner or beneficiary of a foreign trust and would like to discuss a specific structure, please write to contact@auricllc.com.

 
 
 

Comments


Follow us

© 2026 by Auric Private Client Advisory LLC. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy

bottom of page